Notes &
49ers defeat Seahawks 40-21, but questions remain unanswered
While I did predict a Niners’ win, I definitely didn’t expect it to happen like this. San Francisco took advantage of Seattle QB Matt Hasselbeck’s many turnovers, with Alex Smith and the offense doing just enough to put points on the board while benefiting from an often shorter field for them to play with. While winning is great and keeps the team in the playoff race with only 3 games to go, there are still many questions that remain for this underachieving 49er team.
- Was Alex Smith a difference maker in the game, or would Troy Smith have done just as well, if not better? The answer to this was unclear throughout the course of the game, and I’m not sure if there will be a definitive response any time soon. A. Smith made some fairly poor and inaccurate passes, but the playbook did seem expanded with him under center, which may have led to the offensive outburst.
- Was the result indicative of an improved and overpowering San Francisco team, or was it because the Seahawks came unprepared and were outmatched throughout the game? While the Niners obviously played better than in the season opener against the same team, I don’t know if they’re good enough to beat the streaking Chargers next Thursday. I feel like the outcome was a combination of the fact that S.F. came prepared and motivated and the Seahawks were either fatigued or took the 49ers lightly during the week leading up to the game.
- Is this San Francisco team good enough to make the playoffs? This question is probably the most important out of the three, but surprisingly, the easiest for me to answer. Without a doubt, the 49ers are a playoff quality team. They definitely have the talent and at times will dominate their opponent. The keywords there are “at times,” which has been the achilles heel for S.F. all season. They have just been too inconsistent and haven’t adjusted quickly enough to put themselves in a good position to make the playoffs.
So while this team is good enough on paper to make the playoffs, and they just might if they beat San Diego, the real question is do they deserve to make the postseason with the way they’ve played this year? Fortunately, automatic playoff berths don’t factor in if a team should or should not earn the seed, so we might see the 49ers going into Week 17 just needing to defeat the last place Cardinals to win the NFC West and in turn, heading to the playoffs for the first time since 2002. It should be exciting.